Thusness · John Tan

Free to read and share

Books

The content of these ebooks and bonus articles is used to create this website.

Five works, each chapter to read and listen to, most with narrated videos, and twenty-two bonus articles you can read in one sitting. Not sure where to begin? See how to read the books.

The Logical Necessity of aSubstrateless World
John Tan

The main work · 15 chapters

The Logical Necessity of a Substrateless World

A logical case that nothing can be coherently posited as existing from its own side.

The Transition fromAnatta to Emptiness
John Tan

The companion · 23 episodes

The Transition from Anatta to Emptiness

How that case came to be lived: from anatta to a non-substantialist understanding of emptiness.

Nāgārjuna'sMiddle Way
John Tan

The root text · 27 chapters

Nāgārjuna's Middle Way

The Fundamental Verses, chapter by chapter: Sanskrit, a new English translation and a plain explanation with diagrams.

The Observer and theTaste of Presence
John Tan

The shortest way through · 23 chapters

The Observer and the Taste of Presence

From the search for a witness behind experience to the Dzogchen phrase "beyond cause and effect".

The LogicAfter Anatta
John Tan

The newest · 8 steps, 11 questions

The Logic After Anatta

Two ways of thinking, substance and dependency, in eight steps, then applied to eleven big questions. Each step has its own video.

For invited readers

Download the five books and the bonus articles as PDFs

The whole of each book, ready to download, and the bonus articles in the folder Articles. The bonus articles are explorations of the deep concepts in the books and how they apply. The folder opens only for readers John Tan has added: sign in to Google with the email address he added.

Bonus articles

ArticleReadListenWatch
Isn't Energy the Substrate?Why the conserved quantity of physics is not a last substance.Read—Watch
Dependent Designation and the Taste of PresenceFrom the chariot to the immediacy of appearing.Read—Watch
Two Modes, One SeeingDividing and non-dividing mind, dependent arising and spontaneous presence.Read—Watch
Beyond Cause and EffectWhy the question of cause stops applying, and how spontaneous presence and dependent arising meet.Read—Watch
Insubstantial AppearancesVivid, workable and empty: two mistakes about appearances, and four points that loosen both.Read—Watch
Vivid and Nowhere: What a Phenomenon IsSolid, dreamlike or described by physics: every appearance vivid, and none found standing anywhere.Read—Watch
Mind and Consciousness: Both Are Also Singled OutMind, consciousness, luminous clarity and matter: all singled out, all designated, all phenomena. Why I do not say mind is the empty vivid appearing.Read—Watch
One Flame Lights AnotherKarma and rebirth with nothing carried and nothing cut off.Read—Watch
The Illusion of the GivenWhy no hidden thing stands behind what appears: one bowl, many beings, agreement without a hidden substance, mind and object arising together, and many worlds without a container.Read—Watch
The Limits of the ToolsWhy concepts and drawings cannot hold what vividly appears, unfindable and following its conditions, and how to present it anyway.Read—Watch
The Logic of DependencyThe two logics in full: substance and dependency, through change, the eight extremes, identity, convention, continuity and the path. The eight steps unpack it.Read—Watch
Neither Carried Nor CutContinuity with nothing carried over and nothing cut off, seen in the six streams of seeing, hearing, smelling, tasting, touching and thinking.Read—Watch
Annihilation Is an Inherent ViewWhy "it is gone" holds on to the same thing as "it lasts for ever": something can be cut off only if it was there from its own side first.Read—Watch
Science and the DharmaWhere physics and cognitive science come closest to emptiness, and the one step they still leave to the Dharma.Read——
The Lamp That Does Not Light ItselfClear and empty, never a hidden substance.Read—Watch
Causal Efficacy Without Causal PowerCauses work, but no power inside them is ever found. Is that orthodox Madhyamaka and Dzogchen?Read—Watch
Insights and Tastes for PracticeWhat has to be seen, what has to be tasted, and how would I advise someone who practises?Read——
Rainbow Body and EmptinessIf nothing is found, what turns into light? Dzogchen, Gelug, the five lights, and the yang spirit.Read—Watch
The Yang Spirit and the Rainbow BodyIf nothing is found, what turns into light? Dzogchen, Gelug, the five lights, and the yang spirit.Read—Watch
Knowing From SomewhereKnowing From Somewhere: the six higher knowledges, read without a hidden ground.Read—Watch
Three Descriptions, One TasteAnatta, dependent arising and spontaneous presence: one taste, met three times and described three waysRead——
Dependent Arising and DesignationWhat dependent arising and designation say, and what they are for: no power in the cause, no web behind things, the antidote to ignorance, and spontaneous presence.Read——