After Anatta · The Logic · Defined in the meeting
Defined in the Meeting
If there is no self, what is the self we speak of? If past and future do not meet, how does the present arise? If cause and effect do not meet, how does a cause serve as a condition? If they were inherently existent, it would be impossible for them to meet. But they never were. The three questions have one answer. Self, time and cause are dependent arisings. They meet in the empty conventional web, and in that meeting they define each other. Nothing that truly exists was ever produced there, or ceased, or came, or went.
All views and understanding here are my own, from my practice and contemplation. I do not represent any tradition, school or teacher. Where I report what a tradition holds, I try to report it fairly; where I part from it, I say so.
After the negations, three questions keep coming back. I asked them myself along the way.
- If there is no self, then what is the self, or the Self, that we keep talking about?
- If past and future do not meet, how does the present arise?
- If cause and effect do not meet, how does a cause serve as a condition?
They look like three problems. They are one. This article answers all three in the same way, and shows why the answer is the same.
Nothing Left to Negate walks through how one conventional thing forms: a chair, step by step. This article looks at something narrower and closer in: how identities form together. Self and other, past and future, cause and effect. None of them is formed alone.
In brief
- The three questions have one shape. Each starts with two finished things, a self and its experiences, a past and a future, a cause and an effect, and then asks how they connect.
- Every one of them is a dependent arising. There is no self, or Self, except as designated under a specific set of conditions. The same is true of cause and effect, and of past, present and future.
- They meet, and the meeting is where they are defined. In dependent arising, all these meet in the empty conventional web, each defining the others’ identities. They are not finished first and joined afterwards.
- The web is conventional and empty. It is not a network found behind the things. The threads are named together with what they tie, and are not found on their own side either.
- The Middle Way reads clearly this way. Read dependent arising as formation, and Nāgārjuna’s twenty-seven chapters align. What sounded like contradictions came from reading them with things already finished.
- No side wins. Mind is not prior to matter, nor matter to mind; both are empty formations, designated upon conditions. And dependent arising is empty too.
- Nothing comes or goes. All along, no truly existing self, cause, effect, past, present or future was produced or ceased, came or went. Yet the meeting goes on, vivid and working.
The shape of the three questions
Look at how each question is built.
- A self is pictured standing first, and then the question is what it has to do with seeing, thinking and choosing.
- A past is pictured standing behind, a future standing ahead, and then the question is how the present gets between them.
- A cause is pictured standing on one side, an effect on the other, and then the question is how something crosses from one to the other.
In each, the two sides are taken as already finished, each with its own identity, before they relate. Then the relating becomes a puzzle: a bridge, a handover, a carrier, a contact. And Nāgārjuna shows that every such bridge fails. If the two were one, there would be nothing to relate. If they were separate, nothing could relate them: “If effect and cause were one, producer and produced would be the same. If effect and cause were separate, a cause would be no different from a non-cause” (MMK 20.20).
So the answer cannot be a better bridge. It has to take apart the picture that needs one.
My answer, in two sentences
Self and Self, cause and effect, past, present and future, every entity and every phenomenon, is a dependent arising. There is no self or Self except as designated self or Self under a specific set of conditions, and the same goes for the rest.
There in dependent arising, all these meet in the empty conventional web, mutually and dependently defining each other’s identities. All along, no truly existing self, cause, effect, past, present or future was produced or ceased, came or went.
The rest of this article unpacks those two sentences, one question at a time.
The self, and the Self
What is denied. A self that stands on its own: an owner behind the seeing, a doer behind the doing, a someone who would still be there if seeing, hearing, feeling and thinking were taken away. Looked for, it is not found. It is not the aggregates, and it is not something apart from them: “If the self were the aggregates, it would arise and pass away. If it were other than the aggregates, it would not have the marks of the aggregates” (MMK 18.1).
What is left. The self as designated. “I am hungry”, “I promised”, “I will pay the bill”: these work. Actions bear fruit, and promises bind. The self is singled out on the streams of seeing, hearing, feeling and thinking, under a specific set of conditions. It is not arbitrary. I cannot point at the table and call it me.
How it is formed. In What the Logic Is Looking At I described holding an apple. Each sense gives only its own appearing: this hardness, this red, this sweetness. Mental formation, from the habits of the inherent framework, ties them into one solid apple out there, and at the same stroke a “me” in here holding it. The “me” is tied by the same knot as the apple. Self and other are named together, as blue and red appear together in one stroke. Neither is there first.
The specific set of conditions. Take the test in Book 1. Under a general anaesthetic you count backwards from ten, reach seven, and then a nurse is saying your name in another room. In those hours, in the framework of your own experience, no “I” was singled out at all. In the framework of the operating theatre, “the patient” was there the whole time, monitored and charted. Both are correct within their frame. The self is not a thing that was present or absent. It is designated where its conditions are met, in the framework that meets them.
And the Self. When the first self is seen through, there is a quieter one. The clarity of appearing, the sheer vivid knowing of it, is taken as a pure witness, a vast awareness behind everything, the background the world appears in. That is the Self. It is formed the same way: the clarity is singled out, set apart from what appears, and given a place to stand. But the clarity is the appearing’s own. It is not a light shining from somewhere behind. It is designated too, under its own conditions, and searched for, it is not found apart from what appears.
So when I say “there is no self”, I do not mean the word refers to nothing. I mean it refers to nothing standing by itself. Nāgārjuna puts the whole shape in one verse: “Whatever comes to be in dependence on something is not that very thing, and it is not other than it either. So it is neither cut off nor permanent” (MMK 18.10).
Past, present and future
The question is Nāgārjuna’s own. “If the present and the future exist in dependence on the past, then the present and the future would have to be in the past. But if the present and the future are not there in the past, how could the present and the future depend on it?” (MMK 19.1–2). If the present is already inside the past, nothing new arises. If it is outside, they never touch.
What is not found. A present with a width of its own, standing between a past kept somewhere and a future waiting somewhere. Walk across a room. The floor divides into what is behind the foot and what is ahead of it. The now of the step has no width. “A time that does not stay is not grasped, and a time that stays, which could be grasped, is not found” (MMK 19.5).
How the times are formed. The three times are not three places that the present must pass between. They are defined through each other. “Past” is past only with a present and a future; “present” is present only after a past and before a future. And all three are named on change: the hour on the clock’s hands, the year on the seasons, a life on its ageing. So the present does not arise where past meets future. The meeting is where “past”, “present” and “future” get their meaning at all.
In real time. Before any lining up, each instant is complete: the seeing is wholly seeing, the sound wholly sound. Nothing in it waits to be handed on, and nothing is missing that a carrier would have to supply. The question “what carries this into the next?” arises only when the mind steps back and lines the instants up. Once they are lined up, the right description of the row is neither same nor different, neither carried nor cut. As I put it in Neither Carried Nor Cut, that is not a gap continuity has to cross. It is the continuity.
What stays. The train still leaves at nine, and you can miss it. Seeds still come before sprouts, and actions ripen later. Time functions validly as the measure of change, within the frameworks that measure it. What is denied is a time that stands by itself, a river flowing when nothing happens, or a deep “Now” that everything appears in. That last one sounds like insight. It is the same habit, the present made into a ground.
Cause and effect
The dilemma. If cause and effect meet, they are there at once, and then nothing is making anything: a potter beside a finished pot is not making it (MMK 20.7). If the cause hands its power across and then ceases, it would have two selves, one that was given and one that ceased (MMK 20.5). If it ceases without giving, the effect has no cause. Every way of picturing the crossing fails.
How a cause becomes a cause. Not by reaching across. “‘These are conditions, because in dependence on them that arises’: so it is said” (MMK 1.5). Being a condition is not a power the cause carries over to the effect. It is named from the effect’s side, together with the effect, as long and short are named together. Fire and fuel are the same: “If a thing is established in dependence on another, and that other is established in dependence on the first, then which is established in dependence on which?” (MMK 10.10). The baker and the baking too: “The agent proceeds in dependence on the action, and the action proceeds in dependence on the agent. We see no other basis on which they could be established” (MMK 8.12).
This is not about clocks. “Named together” does not mean “happening at the same time”. The seed still comes before the sprout. Candrakīrti and Tsongkhapa both keep that order, and so do I. What is mutual is the defining, not the timing.
The pieces were never two. In Causal Efficacy Without Causal Power I put it more sharply: conditions are the appearing. Spark, fuel and air are not little things lined up underneath the flame, which later get together and build it. They are the one burning, cut into parts by a framework that wants to explain something or get something done. So “the conditions produce the appearing” turns out to be the appearing, divided, said to produce itself.
How it serves. The serving is the pattern holding: when this is, that is. Leave out the yeast and the loaf is flat, in every kitchen. That reliability needs no handover. A seed with its own nature could not give rise to anything. It could not change, so it could not sprout. Things work, and what works is found empty; a thing with its own nature could not work at all.
Where they meet: the empty conventional web
So do things meet, or not?
They meet. I do not say “nothing meets”. That would be the annihilation reading, and it leans on the same picture it denies. What I say is that the meeting is where the identities are formed. Self and other, cause and effect, past and future do not arrive finished and then touch. Each becomes what it is only with the others. The meeting is not a contact between two things. It is the mutual defining itself.
And the meeting happens in a web: conditions, relations, frameworks, agreements, all entangled. That web is conventional. It functions validly as a web, and I can trace its threads for any purpose I like: the cook’s, the chemist’s, the physicist’s. But the web is empty too. Its threads are named together with what they tie. “A thing does not come into contact with itself, and different things do not come into contact either. Coming into contact, having come into contact, and the one who brings them into contact are not found” (MMK 14.8). The line is as unfindable as the dot.
This is the guard I keep. When the things are seen through, the mind likes to keep the relations, a network, a field, Indra’s net, as what is finally there. It is a fine image as long as the net itself is not taken as found. What is left when both the things and the threads are seen through is not a web standing on its own side. It is this, appearing, vivid and working.
Nothing came, nothing went
So the meeting goes on. Selves are designated, times are measured, causes are traced, and all of it works. Yet in all of it, nothing that truly exists was produced, and nothing that truly exists ceased. Nothing came from somewhere, and nothing went anywhere.
Nāgārjuna opens the whole Middle Way with this, in a bow: “Without ceasing, without arising, without annihilation, without permanence, not one thing and not many, without coming and without going: so the fully awakened one taught dependent arising, the quieting of elaborations, peace.”
Read with the three questions in mind, the bow answers them all.
- Without arising, without ceasing: no truly existing present was produced between past and future, and none ceased.
- Without annihilation, without permanence: the self is not cut off at each moment, and it does not go on as the same.
- Not one thing and not many: cause and effect are not one, and not two separate things.
- Without coming, without going: nothing crosses from cause to effect, or from this life to the next.
And it calls this dependent arising, not its opposite. The bow does not describe a stillness behind the working world. It describes the working world, seen rightly.
Reading the Middle Way as formation
Read dependent arising as formation, and the twenty-seven chapters of Nāgārjuna’s Middle Way stop looking like a string of paradoxes. Read one by one, with things already finished in mind, they seem to contradict each other and the world. Nothing arises, yet he keeps the four noble truths. Nothing moves, yet the traveller arrives. No self is found, yet actions bear fruit. Each chapter seems to take something away.
Read as formation, every chapter shows the same thing in a different place. What looked like two finished things that had to meet is two sides defined in the meeting. What looked like a production is a mutual designation. Nothing is taken away except the “on its own”.
- Conditions and combination (Chapters 1, 20). Conditions are conditions only with what arises from them (1.5). Cause and effect are neither one nor separate (20.20). Causes are not denied. A cause is a cause in the meeting.
- Motion and time (2, 19). A goer goes only on a path being gone; the gone over, the not yet gone over and the going are named together (Chapter 2). Past, present and future are defined through each other (19.1–2). Walking and clocks are not denied.
- Senses, aggregates and elements (3, 4, 5). Seeing is seeing only with the seen. “Form is not found apart from the cause of form. And the cause of form is not seen apart from form” (4.1). Space and its characteristic are named together (5.3).
- Pairs that define each other (6, 8, 9, 10). Desire and the one who desires. The agent and the action (8.12). A seer before the seeing: “by what is it designated?” (9.3). Fire and fuel (10.10). In each, neither side comes first.
- Arising, contact and essence (7, 13, 14, 15). Arising, staying and ceasing are found only as named with each other. Contact, and the ones in contact, are not found apart (14.8). Own-nature and other-nature are named together, so neither stands alone (Chapter 15).
- Bondage, action, self and becoming (16, 17, 18, 21). The one who is bound, the one who acts, the one who reaps: each is designated with the binding, the action and the fruit. Coming into being and passing away are not found apart, and not found together either (21.1). So the self is neither cut off nor permanent (18.10).
- Beginnings and the Tathāgata (11, 22). No first limit is known (11.1): a “beginning” is named only with what follows it. The Tathāgata is neither the aggregates nor other than them.
- Error, the four truths, nirvāṇa, the twelve links, views (23–27). Error and right seeing are named together. Chapter 24 says it outright: dependent arising, emptiness, designation and the middle way are one (24.18). Saṃsāra and nirvāṇa are not two places: “between these two, not even the finest gap is found” (25.20). The twelve links in forward order show how suffering forms, and in reverse how it stops forming (26.11–12). Chapter 27 lets go of every view, a view of emptiness included.
So the contradictions were never in the text. They came from reading it with things already finished, and then trying to make them meet. Once dependent arising is seen as formation, and the formation is seen to be empty, the chapters align. Each is clear, and each is tenable: things work, and what works is found empty. A thing with its own nature could not work at all. It could not even be examined in a single chapter.
Why the negating can stop, and why no side wins
Relentless negation. This is also why I call relentless negation incomplete. Negation removes the “on its own”. But if the two finished sides are still pictured, the solidity returns and has to be negated again, and again. Seeing that the sides are defined in the meeting is what completes it. Nothing is left to negate, not because everything was negated, but because nothing was ever set up apart (Nothing Left to Negate).
No side is privileged. So in dependent arising there is no argument of mind over matter, or of matter over mind. Mind is not prior to matter, and matter is not prior to mind. Both are empty dependent formations, designated upon conditions, each singled out with the other. Neither is the ground the other stands on. The brain still matters, and anaesthesia still stops pain; these hold fully, as conventions (Mind and Consciousness: Both Are Also Singled Out).
Dependent arising is empty too. It is not a new ground under mind and matter, or under anything else. It is designated as well: “That is a designation in dependence” (MMK 24.18). Looked for, it is not found on its own side.
Three guards
The meeting is not a contact between finished things. Every time I catch myself picturing two sides first and a relation second, I have rebuilt the problem. The sides are defined in the meeting.
The web is not a new ground. The empty conventional web is how the meeting is described, not a stuff underneath it. Relations are designated together with what they relate. Neither stands alone.
Designation is not free. “Under a specific set of conditions” is the point. A name holds or fails as it is used. A shadow cannot be designated a bridge. Tsongkhapa’s three checks sort the conventions that work from the ones that do not: known to ordinary cognition, not overturned by another sound ordinary cognition, not overturned by analysis of how things ultimately are.
Try it
- Catch the two finished sides. Next time a “how do they connect?” question comes up, about mind and body, self and world, a cause and its effect, stop and ask: did I picture the two sides first? Then look at how each is defined only with the other.
- Find where the self is designated. At some point today, notice the moment “I” is singled out: a name called, a choice made, a pain that is “mine”. Notice the conditions it needs. Then notice a stretch when it is not singled out at all, absorbed in a task, and nothing is missing.
- Look for the present. Walk slowly across a room and try to find the now of the step: not the part behind, not the part ahead. Notice that nothing is lost when no slice is found. The walk goes on.
Read more
- Neither Carried Nor Cut: continuity without a carrier, moment to moment.
- Causal Efficacy Without Causal Power: no power in the cause; conditions are the appearing.
- Beyond Cause and Effect: spontaneous presence, the flat empty web.
- Nothing Left to Negate: how one conventional thing forms, step by step.
- Dependent Arising and Designation: conditions are the appearing, and not a web.
- Mind and Consciousness: Both Are Also Singled Out: mind and matter as two cuts of one appearing.
- The Lamp That Does Not Light Itself: clarity, never a light that shines on itself.
- Annihilation Is an Inherent View: “it is not” leans on “it is”.
- Step 7, Function Without Substance: a thing with its own nature would be sealed.
- Nāgārjuna, Middle Way: Chapter 1, Chapter 18, Chapter 19, Chapter 20.
Words to know
- Dependent arising: Coming to be in dependence on causes, parts and designation. Not a process that produces things, but how everything that appears appears.
- Designation: Singling something out as “this” rather than “that”, by seeing, thinking or naming, under a specific set of conditions. Not a sticker on a thing that was there first.
- Mutual designation: Two sides named together, each only with the other: long and short, cause and effect, self and other. About defining, not about timing.
- Empty conventional web: The entanglement of conditions, relations and frameworks in which identities are defined. It functions validly as convention, and is not found on its own side.
- The eight extremes: Arising and ceasing, annihilation and permanence, one and many, coming and going. Nāgārjuna’s opening bow says dependent arising is free of all eight.