After Anatta · The Logic · Start here: seven questions
Why Nāgārjuna Freezes the Modern Mind
Seven questions to try, here and now, before deciding that Nāgārjuna's arguments are only old quarrels.
All views and understanding here are my own, from my practice and contemplation. I do not represent any tradition, school or teacher. Where I report what a tradition holds, I try to report it fairly; where I part from it, I say so.
Many readers laugh off Nāgārjuna's arguments. "We simply don't think this way." Before you decide, try seven questions. Do each one now, not in your head. And don't answer with what you have read. Answer with what is here.
1. Hit a bell
Strike a bell, or any glass or cup.
Obviously the sound is somewhere: in the bell, out there in the room.
So where exactly is it? In the bronze? The bronze alone makes no sound. In the air? Air is everywhere and silent. In the ear? The ear alone hears nothing. Then it must be in the mind, a copy of the sound in here. So look in the mind. Where in it? Is the mind a place, with the sound sitting inside? Look for the mind the way you looked for the sound. Is it found?
And where did the sound come from? Where does it go as it fades?
2. Blow out a flame
Light a match or a candle. Then blow it out.
Obviously the flame was there, and now it has gone.
Gone where? North, east, south, west? Up? Into nothing? If it went somewhere, where is it now? If it became nothing, what was it that became nothing? And while it burned, was it one flame all along, or a new flame each instant? If one, how did it flicker and change? If new each instant, what was "the flame"?
3. Find the present moment
Listen to the clock, or to your own breath.
Obviously time is flowing: from the past, through now, into the future, carrying everything along whether or not anything happens.
Find the "now". Is it arising, or ceasing? If it stays even an instant, that instant has a start and an end, and splits again into what is gone and what is not yet. If it does not stay at all, when is it ever there? Now take away every change: the clock, the breath, the thoughts. Is there time left over, flowing on its own?
4. Find the space
Move your hand slowly through the air in front of you.
Obviously space is there: an empty room that would remain if everything in it were taken away.
Was the room there before the hand, empty and waiting? Then what made it room, with nothing in it? Did the hand bring it? Then what was the hand moving into? Now take away the hand, the walls, the earth, the stars. Is there a space left over? Where is it? What is it like? Is it something? Is it nothing?
5. Strike a match
Strike a match, or remember striking one.
Obviously the match has the power to make fire.
Was the fire already in the match? Then why wasn't it burning in the box? Was it not in the match at all? Then why does a match light, and a wet stone not? Did the match hand its power over to the flame? Then it would have to give the power away and keep it at the same time. Did the match cease without handing anything over? Then the flame has no cause. Are match and flame one thing? Then the match was already the flame. Are they two? Then any stick would do.
6. Toss an apple
Toss an apple from one hand to the other.
Obviously one solid apple flew through the air.
Where exactly is it? The red you see? The press on your palm? The weight? The sweet smell? The arc through the air? Is the apple one thing, or many appearings: a colour, a touch, a weight, a smell, each arising with its own conditions? If it is one, which of these is it? If it is many, what makes them one apple? And is there an apple behind them all, holding them as its own? Look for it.
And who threw it? Is there a thrower behind the throwing, a catcher behind the catching?
7. Neither carried nor cut
Think of yesterday and today, or of the match and its flame.
Obviously the past leads into the present, and the cause leads into the effect.
Did something carry over from yesterday into today, from the match into the flame? Then what crossed, and where is it now? Was nothing carried at all, the one simply cut off from the other? Then how does yesterday shape today, and why does the match light? Neither carried nor cut: then how can cause and effect, past and future, ever meet? How is that even possible?
Who hears?
Listen to the sound again.
Obviously someone is hearing it: you, just behind the ears.
Look for the hearer. Is the hearer the hearing? Then no one is hearing. Is the hearer apart from the hearing? Then what does it hear with? Look right where the hearer should be. What is there?
Scary, or free?
Now turn it on yourself. No holder behind the hearing. No one behind the striking or the throwing. Only appearances: vivid, reliable, and as unfindable as a magic show or a dream.
Does that sound scary, or free?
Notice which comes up first. Don't argue with it.
Where the mind stops
Notice what happened each time. The mind reached for an answer and found nothing to stand on. It tried "it does", then "it doesn't", then "both", then "neither". Then it stopped.
Stay there.
Stop here. Don't read on yet. Go back to the questions, with a real bell, a real flame, a real step into the next moment, for a day or a week. The answers below mean little until the mind has stopped on its own. Read them only when you have.
The answers
What the questions asked. Look back at them:
- Where did it come from? Where did it go? The bell's sound, the flame: coming and going.
- Does it arise? Does it cease? The present moment: arising and ceasing.
- Does it last? Is it cut off? The flame blown out, the power handed over, yesterday and today: permanence and annihilation.
- Is it one? Is it many? The same, or different? The apple and its appearings, the flame from instant to instant, the match and its fire: one and many.
- And under all of them: where is it? The bell, the mind, the room.
These are the eight extremes.
Why the mind stopped. It is not Nāgārjuna's strangeness. It is our own habit, caught in the act: the habit that first sets up an "it", and then asks where it came from, where it went, whether it lasts, whether it is the same or different. We name past, present and future, and draw the lines between them; then we take the lines as standing on their own. We attach every action to a self, "I hear", "I strike", "I throw"; then we take the self as there. We insist the sound and the apple exist out there, on their own; then we look for them, and nothing is found. We think this way so deeply that it can take decades to notice.
Nothing here denies the sound, the flame, the moment, the room, the fire or the apple. Only the "it" behind them was looked for, and not found.
Free from the eight. Strike the bell once more. It comes from nowhere and goes nowhere, not even nowhere. It is not in the bell, the air, the ear or the mind. Yet it rings, clearly, every time the bell is struck.
Nāgārjuna opens his work by bowing to exactly this: dependent arising, "without ceasing, without arising, without annihilation, without permanence, not one thing and not many, without coming and without going" (MMK 1, homage).
Being free from these is not strange. It is how a sound already is. What is not normal is our way of asking.
Neither carried nor cut. How can cause and effect, past and future, ever meet, when the past is already gone? Look at what makes them unable to connect: the "they". The question takes the past deed and the future fruit, the cause and the effect, as things that were really there, so that one of them can now be "gone" and the other must be reached across a gap. But there is no "they" to be gone. They were never there as entities. They were only conventionally designated as such, in dependence on each other, as long and short are.
The substantialist also says nothing is really gone, but for the opposite reason: the stuff remains. The quarks, electrons, protons and neutrons are still here, zillions of years later; the atoms of our bodies are as old as the universe. Continuity is kept by something that lasts underneath.
The non-substantialist goes further. It keeps nothing underneath, not the deed, not the stuff, not even the quarks (the quarks too are designated, and physics goes on working), and goes on deconstructing until the question itself, "how do they connect?", is seen through at its origin. Nothing is gone, and nothing endures, because no "they" ever stood to go or to stay. That cuts all the roots. The question is not answered; it has nothing left to stand on. And the designations go on working: the seed still gives the sprout, yesterday still shapes today, and karma still ripens.
Scary, or free. If fear came up, look at what was afraid: something that would be lost, an "it" that could be cut off. That is the habit of an "it" again, only looking backwards. Nothing that was there is lost. The bell still rings; the match still lights; the apple still lands in the other hand. The hearing is centreless, effortless, seamless and intimate: no one in the middle holding court, no doer grinding away.
Where the reasoning is
Don't take the answers as a conclusion. Go back to the questions, again and again, in a sound, a flame, a breath. When you want the reasoning, it is here:
- The bell, and the mind it is not in: The Limits of the Tools, "Vivid, and not found".
- The flame blown out: the Buddha's own question to Vacchagotta, in which direction a fire that has gone out has gone (Aggivacchagotta Sutta, MN 72); and Annihilation Is an Inherent View.
- The present moment: Does It Arise or Cease?, and Nāgārjuna's Middle Way, Chapter 19.
- The space: Nāgārjuna's Middle Way, Chapter 5.
- The match: Causal Efficacy Without Causal Power, and Nāgārjuna's Middle Way, Chapter 1 and Chapter 20.
- The apple: Dependent Arising: If You Think You Understand, You Don't, "Tossing an apple: the whole view in one moment".
- The hearer: Decoding Anatta and MMK Chapter 3.
- Neither carried nor cut: Neither Carried Nor Cut, and Nāgārjuna's Middle Way, Chapter 20 (no meeting, no gap).
- Scary, or free: Annihilation Is an Inherent View.
- The eight extremes: Chapter 3, Unfindability and Freedom from the Eight Extremes (The Logical Necessity of a Substrateless World).
- Do we really think this way? The Logic of Dependency, "Do We Actually Think Substantially?", and my talk Do We Think Inherently? An Honest Clinical Interrogation.
- Why seeing, not reasoning alone: Seeing Comes First.