Thusness · John Tan

After Anatta · The Logic · How it all fits together

Two Backbones, One Spine

How The Post-Anatta Pathway and Dependent Arising: The Journey run along one spine, and how the rest of the site hangs on it.

The site hangs on one spine: the steps of my journey, from the questions (S1) to authenticating (S7). Two pages run the length of it. The Post-Anatta Pathway orders the reading by stage, the way I went. Dependent Arising: The Journey groups the same ground by what dependent arising had to undo. Every other page, book chapter and MMK chapter is tied to a step on the spine.

Most of this map is clickable: click a stage, a part or a step to open it.

Pathway stageJourney partalso serves a later step

The map, step by step

Left, the Pathway's stages; right, the Journey's parts. The Journey keeps its own order, so its numbers cross the spine: part 5, cause and effect, answers S4 before parts 3 and 4 reach vividness at S5.

The Post-Anatta PathwaySpineDependent Arising: The Journey
S1QuestionsThe freeze questions: does this moment arise or cease, where did the flame go, who hears.
S3ToolsTwo logics, what is negated, designated not found, the four corners, the two traps; the disease of relentless negation.
S4AnswersDependent arising and the two truths: no “they” to be gone; neither carried nor cut; the importance of seeing the formation in dependent arising.
S6Spontaneous presenceComplete as it is, nothing behind it.
The whole Pathway is the map of this
S7AuthenticatingSeen again and again: the desync, practice, the tastes.
The whole Journey is the hub of this

Where the two backbones meet

These pages sit on both. Read one, and you are on both paths at once.

The Explorations: the spine applied

Rebirth, death, realms, powers, science, energy, ethics and practice. Each Exploration applies the spine to one topic, and opens by naming the steps and pages it rests on.

How the rest of the site hangs on the spine

  • The doorway. "Seven Questions" in the menu opens Why Nāgārjuna Freezes the Modern Mind: S1, the way in to both backbones.
  • Next, in the journey's order. The Previous and Next links at the foot of each page walk the spine, from the seven questions to the Pathway and this map.
  • The books. Each book chapter opens with "Read with": the pages here that cite it, in the spine's order.
  • The MMK chapters. Each of the 27 chapters of Nāgārjuna's Middle Way opens with the question it answers, linked back to the doorway.
  • Words. Key terms link to where they are explained, the first time a page uses them.