Thusness · John Tan

After Anatta · Explorations · Inner Winds and Subtle Body Practices · Zoom in

When Thinking Drains the Qi

Why a morning of hard thinking leaves me short of qi, why half an hour of exercise brings it back, how this fits the Taoist Three Treasures (精气神), and the popular explanations that turn out to be wrong.

All views and understanding here are my own, from my practice and contemplation. I do not represent any tradition, school or teacher. Where I report what a tradition holds, I try to report it fairly; where I part from it, I say so.

These are my own notes and my own plan, not medical advice.

A zoom-in of the exploration Inner Winds and Subtle Body Practices.

What I noticed

One morning I noticed something simple. When I focus too much on mental work, I feel a lack of qi. It is as if thinking itself uses the qi up. Then, when I exercise for half an hour, the qi is strong again. I felt it had something to do with blood circulation.

So I asked a second question. Would it be better to move three times a day, for a short time each: in the morning, at lunch, and in the evening after dinner? The idea was to keep the blood flowing, keep the energy up, and clear the blockage that builds when I concentrate for too long.

I put both questions to an AI. Later I asked another AI tool to check the first answer against the research and the classical texts. Then I checked both myself. This article is what is left after that checking.

The short version: the observation holds, and so does the three-session plan. But the most popular explanation of why it works is wrong. The correction is more interesting than the original story.

In brief

  • The feeling is genuine; the usual story is not. A morning of hard thinking does leave me drained, and movement does restore me. But thinking does not pull a flood of blood to the head.
  • Sitting is a big part of the problem. Hours of sitting still let blood settle in the legs and slightly lower blood flow to the brain. Short walks prevent this.
  • The tired brain is not simply out of fuel. One study found a chemical, glutamate, building up in the front of the brain after a day of hard mental work. The fatigue may be the brain slowing itself down, not running dry.
  • The Yellow Emperor’s Inner Classic already named it: 思则气结, “thinking knots the qi”. Knotted, not used up.
  • Three short sessions fit both views. Morning to start the flow, lunch to break the knot, evening to settle.
  • Qi here is a way of describing how the body feels and works, not a hidden stuff. The language of 精气神 is useful. It does not need a substance behind it.

The popular story, and where it goes wrong

The first AI answer told a neat story. The brain is only about 2% of body weight but uses about 20% of the body’s energy. So when I think hard, it said, “the body routes a massive amount of glucose, oxygen and blood flow directly to the brain”, and this drains the rest of the system. Mental work “hyper-focuses circulation to the head”, and blood and qi “pool in the upper body”.

It sounds right. It matches the feeling of a heavy, full head. But most of it does not hold up.

Misconception 1: “Thinking pulls a massive amount of blood and energy to the brain”

The first half is true. The brain is about 2% of the body’s weight and uses about 20% of its energy. But it uses that much all the time, even at rest, even in sleep. Hard thinking adds only a few percent on top. Solving a difficult problem costs the brain little more than daydreaming does.

Blood flow to the brain is also held steady by the body. Tightly. The brain is not allowed to take a big share of blood away from the limbs just because I am concentrating. So “thinking drains the body’s blood” is not what happens.

Misconception 2: “Blood and qi pool in the head”

Here the truth runs the other way. In 2018, Sophie Carter and her colleagues measured blood flow in a main artery of the brain while people sat for four hours without a break. Blood flow to the brain went down, a little but clearly. Without the legs moving, blood returns to the heart more slowly and settles in the lower body.

In the same study, a two-minute easy walk every 30 minutes stopped the drop completely.

So the heavy head and sluggish legs I feel after a long morning at the desk are not from too much blood up top. They come from too little movement below, together with what is happening inside the brain itself (next point).

Misconception 3: “The tired brain has run out of fuel”

Another common idea is that a tired brain has burned up its sugar. The research points somewhere else.

In 2022, Antonius Wiehler and his colleagues in Paris scanned people’s brains at the start and end of a long working day. Those who did hard mental tasks all day had more glutamate in the front side of the brain (the lateral prefrontal cortex) by evening. Glutamate is a chemical the brain uses to pass signals. These people also made more short-term, impulsive choices by the end of the day.

The researchers suggest the brain slows down its own effortful control when glutamate builds up, a kind of protective brake. That is their hypothesis, not a proven fact, and the study was small. But it fits my experience better than “out of fuel”. It feels less like an empty tank and more like a jam.

Misconception 4: “Exercise flushes the waste out of the brain”

The AI answer said exercise “acts as a flush, clearing these byproducts”. That is a nice image, but no study I found shows a short workout washing glutamate out of the brain. What is shown is narrower: short walking breaks keep blood flow to the brain from falling, and exercise helps attention and mood. I keep the benefit and drop the flushing story.

Misconception 5: “Short exercise snacks beat one long workout”

Short, frequent breaks are clearly better at one thing: breaking up long sitting. That is what my problem is. But this does not make one long workout worse in general. For fitness, both count. The three-session plan is the right tool for a desk-bound thinker, not a law for everyone.

What the classical texts say

思则气结: thinking knots the qi

The best classical anchor for my experience is in the Yellow Emperor’s Inner Classic (黄帝内经), Suwen chapter 39 (举痛论). It lists nine ways that states of mind change the qi. On thinking, it says:

思则气结 … 思则心有所存,神有所归,正气留而不行,故气结矣。

“Thinking knots the qi … When one thinks, the heart holds on to something and the spirit (shen) gathers there. The upright qi stays and does not move. So the qi is knotted.”

This is precise, and it agrees with the modern findings better than the popular story does. The text does not say thinking burns up the qi. It says thinking makes the qi stay and not move. Stuck, not empty. That matches sitting still with blood settling in the legs, and the brain jammed rather than out of fuel.

Misconception 6: where “thinking injures the Spleen” comes from

The AI report placed the saying 思伤脾, “thinking injures the Spleen”, in Lingshu chapter 8 (本神). The four-character saying is from Suwen chapter 5 (阴阳应象大论). Lingshu 8 says something close but different: 脾愁忧而不解则伤意, “when worry in the Spleen is not resolved, it injures the yi (intention)”.

The report also said the Neijing teaches that a weak Spleen fails to make Heart Blood, so the shen cannot settle at night. That idea belongs to later Chinese medicine, not to Lingshu 8. It may be useful, but it should carry its own date.

Misconception 7: 意到气到 as a disease

The report used 意到气到, “where the mind goes, the qi goes”, to explain how thinking drains qi upward. In qigong and taijiquan, 意到气到 is a principle of practice: you guide the qi with attention. Reading it as a cause of illness is the report’s own idea, not the tradition’s.

There is a sound point inside it, though. If attention sits in the head for hours, everything gathers there and nothing moves below. Chinese medicine has a name for this pattern: 上实下虚, “excess above, deficiency below”. As a description of how it feels, it fits well. As a claim about blood literally piling up in the skull, it does not (misconception 2).

The Three Treasures: 精气神

The Taoist Three Treasures (三宝) are jing 精 (essence), qi 气 (breath, energy) and shen 神 (spirit, mind). Inner alchemy treats them as one life force at different degrees of fineness, and its classic path refines essence into qi (炼精化气) and qi into spirit (炼气化神).

A teaching image I find useful is the candle:

  • Jing is the wax and wick: the body’s deep reserves and basic health.
  • Qi is the flame: breath, circulation, the living movement.
  • Shen is the light: awareness, focus, thinking.

Read this way, a long morning of hard thinking is a bright light with a flame that is not being fed, because the body is not moving. In the language of Suwen 39, the shen gathers in one place and the qi stops moving. Exercise feeds and moves the flame again.

I keep this as a description, not a mechanism. The modern details (blood flow, glutamate, sitting) are what actually happens in the body. 精气神 is a way of feeling and naming the whole of it from the inside. The two do not compete.

Qi is not a hidden stuff. As I wrote in Energy Practices, qi first meant vapour and breath. It is not a substance standing behind warmth, movement and alertness. When I say “my qi is weak”, I mean the body feels heavy and slow and the mind feels dull. When I say “my qi is strong”, I mean the reverse. The words point to how the body is working, not to a fluid that thinking drains away.

Three sessions a day

This is the plan I asked about, with what the checking adds:

Window What it does in the body In the language of 精气神
Morning Wakes the body up, gets the blood moving and warms it before the day’s desk work. Feed the flame before the light is asked to shine.
Lunch Breaks up a long morning of sitting and brings blood flow to the brain back up. Untie the knot of 思则气结; correct “excess above, deficiency below”.
Evening, after dinner An easy walk lowers the rise in blood sugar after a meal, because working muscles take up sugar on their own. Keeping it gentle helps the body wind down for sleep. Bring the qi down from the head to the lower body (the lower dantian), so the shen can rest and the jing can recover overnight.

The checking added one more piece. The 2018 study shows that brain blood flow drops when sitting goes on for hours without a break. So three sessions may not be enough on their own during a long morning of writing. Getting up for a short walk in between matters too. The study tested two minutes every 30 minutes.

One thing I dropped: the AI report said morning exercise boosts the cortisol rise that happens after waking. I could not find good support for that, so it is not in the table.

A note on checking AI answers

This article came out of two AI answers, and both needed checking.

The first answer was warm and fluent. It called my observation “profoundly accurate” and my plan “perfect”. But its central explanation, blood rushing to the head, was wrong. Praise is not proof.

The second, a research report, was better. It corrected the blood-flow story and cited two good studies. But it also misplaced classical quotations, stretched one study further than it went, and listed several sources I could not trace at all. One was called a “peer-reviewed preprint”, which is a contradiction: a preprint is a paper before peer review.

What survived the checking is small but solid: my own experience, one line from Suwen 39, and two studies. That is enough.

Sources

  • Huangdi Neijing Suwen 黄帝内经·素问, chapter 39, 举痛论 (the nine qi; 思则气结), and chapter 5, 阴阳应象大论 (思伤脾). English: Paul U. Unschuld and Hermann Tessenow, Huang Di Nei Jing Su Wen (University of California Press, 2011). The translation above is my own plain rendering.
  • Huangdi Neijing Lingshu 黄帝内经·灵枢, chapter 8, 本神.
  • Carter, S. E., Draijer, R., Holder, S. M., Brown, L., Thijssen, D. H. J., and Hopkins, N. D. (2018). Regular walking breaks prevent the decline in cerebral blood flow associated with prolonged sitting. Journal of Applied Physiology 125(3), 790–798.
  • Wiehler, A., Branzoli, F., Adanyeguh, I., Mochel, F., and Pessiglione, M. (2022). A neuro-metabolic account of why daylong cognitive work alters the control of economic decisions. Current Biology 32(16), 3564–3575.
  • My earlier article Energy Practices: Inner Winds, the Subtle Body, and What Frees (on what qi meant and why it is not a substrate).